Healthier Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies (GF & 1 Bowl!)

GFVDF
Jump to Recipe

Peanut butter cookies seem so effortless. Just throw peanut butter and some other random ingredients in your kitchen into a bowl, bake, and voila! — peanut butter cookies! Or so I thought.

This recipe was tested and retested and scrapped and tested again. It caused us so much trouble, but we’re happy to report we stuck with it and are so happy with the results.

Thanks to a little inspo from the talented Liz Moody, we finally got the perfect base formula right, and it’s butter- and oil-free!

The problem with our previous attempts was adding fat in addition to the peanut butter, or adding too many dry ingredients, or too many wet ingredients. Friends, it was touch and go. But this simple, unfussy, 1-bowl technique is perfection!

Simply stir dry ingredients: brown sugar, gluten-free flour, rolled oats, salt, and baking powder.

Then add wet ingredients: peanut butter, egg, vanilla. And stir again. Throw in some chocolate chips and you’re good to go! No chilling required!

This batter comes together in less than 10 minutes. Baking is just another 10 minutes. That means cookies that are ready in like 20 minutes!

Faster cookies = better cookies. It’s science.

We hope you LOVE these cookies! They’re:

Peanut buttery
Salty-sweet
Tender with a slight chew
Studded with chocolate
& Incredibly delicious

These would make the perfect treat to have on hand throughout the week. They also keep well in the freezer for when sweet cravings strike!

If you try this recipe, let us know! Leave a comment, rate it, and don’t forget to tag a photo #minimalistbaker on Instagram. Cheers, friends!

Healthier Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies (GF & 1 Bowl!)

Healthier 1-Bowl Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies made without butter or oil. Perfectly chewy, salty-sweet, and studded with chocolate chips!
Author Minimalist Baker
Print
4.85 from 191 votes
Prep Time 18minutes
Cook Time 12minutes
Total Time 30minutes
Servings 12(Cookies)
Course Dessert
Cuisine Baking, Dairy-Free, Gluten-Free
Freezer Friendly 1 month
Does it keep? 4-5 Days

Ingredients

  • 1/4cuprolled oats(ensure gluten-free friendly as needed)
  • 1/4cupgluten-free flour (or sub other flour, such as almond or unbleached all-purpose)
  • 1/4tspsea salt (plus more for topping)
  • 1/2tspbaking powder
  • 1/2cupbrown sugar (or try subbing coconut sugar, but we only tested with brown)
  • 1/2cupcreamy salted peanut butter (we like Wild Friends — ingredients should only be peanuts and salt)
  • 1/2tspvanilla extract
  • 1largeegg(organic, pasture-raised when possible)
  • 3Tbspdark chocolate chips (dairy-free), chopped (plus more for topping)

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 350 degrees F (176 C) and line a large baking sheet with parchment paper.
  • To a medium mixing bowl, add gluten-free oats, gluten-free flour blend, sea salt, baking powder, and brown sugar and whisk to combine.
  • Add peanut butter (ensure it’s natural and pourable — just peanuts and salt), vanilla, and egg and stir until a tacky dough is formed. Depending on the freshness / drippiness of your peanut butter, you may need to add a little more GF flour if it’s too wet. Or, if it’s too dry or crumbly, compensate with a bit more peanut butter (or a splash of dairy-free milk). We found ours didn't need any adjustments.
  • Stir in chocolate chips. Then scoop out dough in 1 ½ Tbsp amounts (I like using this scoop) and place on prepared baking sheet. Top with another sprinkle of chocolate chips and press down slightly to form into a disc shape.
  • Bake for 10-12 minutes, or until the edges appear slightly golden brown and they’ve expanded to about twice their original size. Remove from oven and let cool on pan for 10 minutes (top with another small sprinkle of salt at this time – optional). Then enjoy (preferably with dairy-free milk).
  • Store cookies well sealed at room temperature up to 4-5 days, in the refrigerator up to 1 week, or in the freezer up to 1 month (let thaw before enjoying).

Video

Notes

*Nutrition information is a rough estimate.
*Recipe adapted from Liz Moody.

Nutrition (1 of 12 servings)

Serving: 1cookiesCalories: 129Carbohydrates: 14.2gProtein: 3.8gFat: 7.4gSaturated Fat: 1.9gPolyunsaturated Fat: 1.12gMonounsaturated Fat: 2.95gTrans Fat: 0gCholesterol: 15.5mgSodium: 111mgPotassium: 91mgFiber: 1.7gSugar: 7.7gVitamin A: 22.54IUVitamin C: 0mgCalcium: 25.8mgIron: 1.08mg

Did You Make This Recipe?

Tag @minimalistbaker on Instagram and hashtag it #minimalistbaker so we can see all the deliciousness!

If you love this recipe...

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment & Rating! Cancel reply

  1. Reeniesays

    These are incredible! Used almond flour and JIF. I predict these will be a staple in our house.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Whoop! We’re so glad you enjoy them, Reenie. Thank you for sharing! xo

      Reply
  2. Jesssays

    I have made this recipe dozens of times and they always go down a treat. The kids love them

    Reply
  3. Sandrasays

    Oh wow. Super simple and super delicious. I doubled the recipe as I had a suspicion they wouldn’t last long (and I no was right). I did add a few grains of salt to each cookie when I took them from the oven and I think it enhanced the flavours. Recipe is a keeper. Thanks!!

    Reply
  4. Haideesays

    Love this recipe, crisp on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside. Used a chia seed egg (1TBSP chia seed + 2.5 TBSPwater) instead of a chicken egg and almond flour. Added a dusting of cinnamon to the batter too. Made it twice now – that shows I really like it!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yum! Thanks so much for the lovely review and for sharing your modifications, Haidee. So glad you enjoy this recipe!

      Reply
  5. Monikasays

    The while family loved these and so easy to make! Used coconut sugar and turned out oh so yummy! This is a keeper!

    Reply
  6. Larensays

    I’ve made these twice now and they were gone too fast. Really yummy! I have two questions: I’ve doubled the recipe both times and it’s only given me 18 cookies, even though they are the size you have said to make them. Are they just itty bitty cookies? Secondly, mine have not doubled in size. They have stayed exactly the same size as I smooshed them down to be. They brown up and taste great, but don’t spread or puff or in any way double. Am I doing something wrong? Yes I have put in the correct amount of baking powder.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Laren, this is so interesting! You’re using a 1 1/2 tablespoon scoop for the dough? And are you making any modifications to the ingredients? The cookies are on the smaller side, about 2-3 inches in diameter… but we’d love to help trouble-shoot if you tell us more about your experience!

      Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoy these cookies, Shannon! Thank you for the lovely review! xo

      Reply
  7. Jesssays

    I made this with almond butter instead of pb and I used a mix of some regular flour and some oat flour. They are delicious!!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Great! We’re so glad they turned out well! Thank you for sharing, Jess! xo

      Reply
    • Reneesays

      They are amazing! I keep making them :). I use coconut sugar, almond flour and cashew butter, which I prefer (I’m not a fan of PB). Yum!

      Reply
  8. Jennsays

    These cookies are deliciously chewy! I used almond flour instead of GF flour and almond butter in place of peanut butter as I didn’t haven’t any on hand. They were a 10/10 and I would do the same substitutions again, though I am dying to try it with peanut butter as I know they will be amazing! I highly recommend trying this recipe :)

    Reply
  9. Jaymesays

    I subbed in coconut sugar and a flax egg and these turned out great! Little bit of crisp on the outside, chewy loveliness on the inside. My new go to cookie. Thank you minimalist baker for this gem 😊

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Whoop! We’re so glad it turned out well! Thank you for sharing, Jayme! xo

      Reply
  10. candace pruittsays

    I made these peanut butter cookies today. There were a hit with me family. You are one of my go to websites, as I can always find recipes with 1 bowl, gluten free, or vegan and easy to make. I love the one bowl concept. I have tried many recipes of yours and my family and I have liked them all. Thank you for all you do, please keep creating.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Aw, thank you so much for your kind words and lovely review, Candace! We are so glad you enjoy our recipes and greatly appreciate you taking the time to share this with us! xoxo

      Reply
  11. Darcysays

    These are my go-to cookies! Such easy ingredients. I also swap out the egg with a flax egg and it works just fine.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! Thanks so much for the great review and for sharing your modifications, Darcy!

      Reply
  12. Kimsays

    These were super quick and easy to make, and so addictive! I used sweetened crunchy peanut butter (because that’s what I had in my cupboard) and a few more semi-sweet chocolate chips than the recipe called for, and they were delicious! Great recipe, and I will definitely be making these again.

    Reply
  13. Conniesays

    Great recipe!! I used a 1/4 cup of coconut sugar and unsweetened chocolate chips, they turned out to be the right sweetness for me. I used unsalted chunky PB as that is what was in the fridge.
    I will definitely make this recipe again, thank you :)

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      So glad to hear you enjoyed them, Connie! Thank you so much for the lovely review and for sharing your modifications! xo

      Reply
  14. Ashsays

    I substituted the egg for a flax egg and used peanut butter that wasn’t in the recipe (as in it had more ingredients than the recipe called for for just peanuts and salt) and they turned out great! They had to cook for about double the time :)

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Michelle! We haven’t tried it this way and the texture will be slightly different, but you could try substituting almond flour (if you’re not nut free) or finely chopped walnuts or pecans. Let us know how it goes if you give it a try!

      Reply
    • Claudiasays

      How about trying it with barley/quinoa/rye/rice/buckwheat flakes instead of oats? :) Depending on where, you live, they could be a bit harder products to find.

      Reply
  15. Sarahsays

    These are simply perfect! I subbed coconut sugar for brown sugar, and used unsalted peanut butter so added 1/4 tsp more salt. Don’t skip the sea salt sprinkle on the top. Rich yet guilt-free.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Sarah! Thanks so much for the lovely review! xo

      Reply
      • lexisays

        Hey there! These COOKIES ARE SUPER GOOD!! I reduced the sugar to 1/4 cup and swapped the flour to dark rye flour instead because I’m only left with that flour at home haha.

        I changed the amount of cookies to 15 cookies because I have a family of 5. And of course, the cookies were smaller.

        Anyways, thank you so much for the wonderful, amazing and healthy cookie recipe!! I felt full after eating 1 cookie and it satisfied me as well.

        I only put a few pieces of chocolate chips into the cookies.
        I’ve estimated the calories per cookie (What I did): 85 calories/cookie.

        Lastly I have a question:
        Why didn’t my cookies expand?
        (Baking powder was added in as well.)

        Reply
        • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

          We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Lexi! Thank you for sharing! It could be that the rye flour is more absorbent, causing them not to expand as much. Next time, we’d suggest starting with less of it to see if that helps!

          Reply
      • Tracysays

        Thx for the recipe! I made for my 4 yo for a treat. So simple! I did measurements by eye, hardly used any sugar (not sure why original recipe has so much?) and instead of choc chips I put a dab of nutino (pretty much Nutella) in the middle. I prob made them too big, but super tasty and no guilt!

        Reply
      • Nikkisays

        Love how delicious and simple this recipe is! I used regular flour rather than GF, used half of the sugar, and added 1/4 c sweetened shredded coconut. It turned out great!

        Reply
  16. Ellysays

    These cookies were so good! My family demolished them, I used oat flour and they turned out amazing, I will definitely make these again <3

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! We’re so glad to hear it, Elly. Thanks so much for taking the time to leave a review! xo

      Reply
  17. Janesays

    I would like to double the recipe and bake as a bar cookie. Would that work, and what size pan should I use?

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hmm, probably an 8×8 or a 10-inch cast iron? Let us know if you try!

      Reply
  18. Angelinasays

    This recipe is AMAZING!!! it is super easy and delicious!!! I forgot to put in the egg and it turned out fine.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoy it, Angelina! Thanks so much for the lovely review! xo

      Reply
  19. Gabbysays

    These are really nice. I needed a bit of almond milk to mix them to a better dough and next time I’d use half the sugar, were a tad too sweet for me but delicious nonetheless.

    Reply
  20. Maxinesays

    Super easy cookies with a not so guilty feel. Very satisfying! There are only 2 of us in our household and these will not even last 4 days before the need to refrigerate or freeze. Looks like I’m baking these in a larger quantity and I can take to work for morning tea, I’m always taking home baked goodies into work for sharing and I have no doubt your recipe will be a smash hit!

    Reply
  21. Tylersays

    Addictive!!! I used a flax egg so used ap flour so there was some gluten to go with the flax egg. I also put in some plant milk b/c that dough was thick and hard to mix. Maybe it was supposed to be hard to mix though b/c texture of my cookies did not quite look like the photos. Tasted delicious and took no time to make. Will definitely be making these again!

    Reply
  22. Janandasays

    Delicious! I subbed maple syrup for the sugar, adding almond flour to make up for the extra liquid. The result was DYNAMITE!!! My husband says, “the best cookies he’s ever had”.

    Reply
  23. Kathleensays

    My 19 year old son said “these are the best GF ones you’ve made, they don’t taste weird” and my spouse also said they are the best ones. I used flax meal “eggs” and did use 2 splashes of soy milk (made 24, there are only 8 left – so heads up, bingeable). Very easy to make. I did press them a bit after rolling in a ball. They hold their shape well and are especially good a couple hours after cooled. The sea salt on top is perfect!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Kathleen. We are so glad you and your family enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  24. Pamsays

    So good, so easy, and so delicious! I’ll have to play with dif types of chocolate chips. I used bittersweet this time.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Pam. We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  25. Beckysays

    This is my go to, quick, easy, fantastically delicious cookie recipe. I use 1/2 cup coconut sugar and no one can tell they’re healthier than the average cookie. These are phenomenal.

    Reply
  26. Angela Kellysays

    Tried this healthier recipe for the first time today and my family and I loved it! I used organic crunchy peanut butter, almond flour and reduced the amount of brown sugar. I also skipped the chocolate chips and the cookies were still delicious! We’ll be making these cookies again!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! We’re so glad you and your family enjoyed it, Angela. Thanks so much for sharing! xo

      Reply
  27. Heidisays

    For a healthy-ish cookie, these taste great and are fool-proof.. They were a hit with everyone at home.

    Definitely will be a go-to when craving something sweet.

    Reply
  28. Alicesays

    Just made these! And they are delicious! Measurements worked perfectly. I couldn’t find dairy free choc chips, but found sugar free ones and they work great. Can’t wait to snack on these.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Alice! Thanks so much for sharing! Enjoy life is our favorite brand for dairy-free chocolate chips.

      Reply
  29. Sherrysays

    I made these 100% as is and they were 100% perfect. Don’t skip the salt on top! Divine! Thanks again for a wonderful recipe!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Sherry. Thanks so much for the lovely review! xo

      Reply
      • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

        We’d suggest a healthy pinch in addition to the 1/4 tsp. Hope that helps!

        Reply
  30. Lexysays

    I doubled the recipe, and I made a lot of subs:
    – ½ coconut sugar, ½ monk fruit sugar and a splash of molasses to mimic brown sugar
    – ½ crunchy peanut butter, ½ almond butter
    – extra GF flour (almond butter is runny and molasses is liquid)
    – added cinnamon
    – my oven sucks so I did 13 mins at “360” and they still came out quite soft

    Reply
  31. Shenika Govendersays

    This recipe is by far my favorite peanut butter cookie recipe! They were so easy to make and tasted so good! Definitely recommend this recipe!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Shenika! Thanks so much for the lovely review! xo

      Reply
  32. Natsays

    I made these with 1/4 cup of coconut sugar only, and used coconut flower. I also used Stevia chocolate chips. Slightly underbaked them at 10 minutes to keep them chewy, and they turned out awesome for gluten free, refined sugar free cookies!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks for sharing, Nat! Coconut flour is more absorbent, so if you make them again, you might want to try starting with slightly less. Hope that helps!

      Reply
  33. Ilhansays

    These cookies are SO SO good! I used JIFS pb and heated it over a skillet on low heat to get a thinner pb texture. I allowed it too cool before adding in the egg and it turned out so soft and perfect. The sea salt on top is a must!!!

    Reply
  34. Marziesays

    I use raw (not roasted) peanuts to make peanut butter. Do you think I can make good cookies out of this raw peanu butter?

    Reply
  35. Michellesays

    This is our new go-to cookie recipe!! As I have one child who loves peanut butter and one with an egg and specific nut allergies who doesn’t, I sub the peanut butter with almond butter and add a wee bit of cacao powder. I use almond flour, coconut sugar and a flax egg, and these are perfection!! Slightly chewy when cooked just right, and delicious! Finally, a cookie that pleases them both! Very quick and easy too. Thank you 🙏

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you and your family enjoyed them, Michelle! Thanks so much for the lovely review! xo

      Reply
  36. Nadia Rehmansays

    These were delicious! Used a flax egg and they held together just fine. Since my peanut butter was honey roasted, I used 1/3 cup sugar and that worked well. This was so easy to make, with ingredients that are usually at hand. Great for prepping on a Sunday night when you need snacks for the coming week!

    Reply
  37. chloesays

    These were so good! I used Wild Friends Peanut+Cashew butter and only 1/4 cup of coconut sugar – they were sweet, salty and so satisfying! My batch made 9 cookies.

    Reply
  38. Arianasays

    Love this recipe! I am not vegan or gluten intolerant so I used all purpose flour and regular dark chocolate chips. Otherwise followed this recipe exactly (appreciate the metric conversion!) and they were a hit. I also really like the base recipe yields only 12 cookies. Good for me as I could easily eat all 12 in one sitting. I’ll definitely be making them again :)

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed this recipe, Ariana! Thanks so much for the lovely review and feedback on the metrics =)

      Reply
  39. chandrasays

    Always a go-to. Anytime I am craving a cookie I come back to this recipe. Comes together so fast and are just amazing.

    Reply
  40. Robinsays

    These are my new favorite sweet treat. I stumbled upon this looking for a quick and easy pantry peanut butter cookie recipe. Little did I know I was discovering something absolutely amazing. A to-die-for cookie with no butter?!

    I also happened to have fresh ground peanut butter from my local Co-Op which I think makes it that much better. I also finished it with Maldon flaked sea salt.

    I love that they are one bowl, and easy ingredients. I feel like everyone needs to know about this recipe!!

    Thank you so much for discovering this goodness!

    Reply
  41. Brandonsays

    Really enjoyed this recipe. The cookies are rich and filling, and very tasty. Even my mom like them and she doesn’t like peanut butter! Bravo!

    Reply
  42. Heenasays

    These cookies are addictive, even my gluten eating friends loved them so much I had to make another batch. I added walnuts to the batter.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We haven’t tried that, but we’d suggest more flour and/or maybe adding some chopped nuts? Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
  43. Minhsays

    This recipe is great. I have been remaking them at least 3 times now and they always came out delicious. This third variation I’m using a peanut cacao butter instead of just plain PB and used white choc chips, they are currently in the oven and I’m so excited to see the result :D

    Reply
  44. Sofiasays

    I used sprouted wheat flour instead of GF, and coconut sugar instead of brown, and they came out wonderfully! Definitely making again, will likely try another flour just to mix things up. Thank you for this simple and delicious recipe!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad they turned out well, Sofia! Thanks so much for sharing! xo

      Reply
  45. Jeannesays

    I ended up making these with GF flour after all.
    The only thing I changed was I used 1/3 cup brown sugar vs. 1/2.
    My natural peanut butter had no salt and I was a little concerned (please advise for future cookies) but if it made a difference I didn’t notice.
    They were delicious!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Jeanne, we’re so glad you enjoyed them! We’d suggest just adding an extra pinch of sea salt next time. But it won’t make a huge difference.

      Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Jeanne, we haven’t tried that, but maybe? We think a mix of cornstarch and a more dense flour such as brown rice flour would be better. Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
  46. Laura Ssays

    This has been our go to cookie recipe since you posted it! I usually don’t double the recipe but I did today and swapped out the egg for flax egg. Equally delicious!
    I might not ever double again because really its so hard not to just eat them all. SO good! Thanks for having the best food blog!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Whoop! We’re so glad you enjoy it, Laura! Thanks so much for your kind words and lovely review! xo

      Reply
  47. Alexisays

    Made these today with minimal changes: didn’t have quite enough peanut butter, so I used a few tablespoons of almond butter to make up the difference. Added 2 tsp of molasses and a few tablespoons of almond milk to get a better texture. Oh, and I put the oats in a blender for a bit to make the oats a bit smaller. Baked for 10 min and they’re perfect. Will def make again.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Alexi! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Cindy, we haven’t tried it that way so we can’t guarantee results. But if you try it, we’d suggest starting with less as it may be more absorbent. Let us know how it goes!

      Reply
  48. Robert Van Dorensays

    I think I made this before, going to try it again. I remember adapting with a Julia/Martha Stewart recipe. The constant rolling video of other websites was annoying enough (extremely annoying) that I will remember not to open them. Thank you for providing good usable information in a civilized format!

    Reply
  49. Ashleysays

    I usually don’t love healthier cookie recipes but these are SO GOOD. They taste like a regular peanut butter cookie. I followed almost exactly, but used all purpose flour & took out the chocolate chips. Also made my mini & only baked for 8 mins. So chewy!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Ashley! Thanks so much for the lovely review!

      Reply
  50. Elizabethsays

    These were a big hit! Quick and easy too. I’m a fan of your DIY gluten-free flour and use it often. Before baking, I sprinkled with a little Maldon sea salt flakes. Yum!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! We’re so glad to hear it! Thanks so much for sharing, Elizabeth!

      Reply
  51. Christinesays

    Hi! Is it possible to make these with regular Peanut Butter, like JIF? Or, does it need to be the drippy kind?

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’ve only tried with the drippy kind, so we’re not certain! Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
      • chelseasays

        This works fine with JIF, I just add a little milk or milk sub. I’ve made these a few times. Love them!

        Reply
  52. Ulwisays

    My siblings loved the cookies so much I whipped up another batch in just 20 minutes. I love how quick the cookies are.
    I used quick-cooking oats instead of rolled, almond flour plus a little bit of gluten free flour, and a bit less sugar than called for. I also left out the chocolate chips. I added some toasted shredded coconut to my second batch.
    I pressed the cookies down a lot to make them thinner and crispier as I found they didn’t crisp up too well.
    Thanks for a delicious, chewy cookie!

    Reply
  53. Tiffany Ksays

    I was planning to make your fudge recipe but didn’t have enough chocolate in the pantry so I baked these cookies instead for our family. They loved them! I subbed Whole wheat flour for the gluten free flour, and used coconut sugar instead of the brown sugar. They were delicious! I should have doubled the recipe.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad your family enjoyed them, Tiffany! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  54. Cherise Smithsays

    These were an immediate hit!!! Mine were a little bit crumbly but no one cared because they tasted so good!!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad everyone enjoyed them, Cherise! For a less crumbly texture, make sure to use a creamy, drippy peanut butter. Hope that helps!

      Reply
  55. Foramsays

    Tried this today! Came out tasting great but the cookies didn’t spread as much as yours. Any idea why? I followed the recipe exactly except that I used almond flour.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      It could be the almond flour! Otherwise, maybe your peanut butter was thicker and less drippy?

      Reply
  56. Katsays

    I made these last night and they came out looking like I reached in and pulled them straight out of the photos! Not only did they look amazing, they tasted even better! I loved that they weren’t too sweet because I always end up craving more cookies and these were perfect because I didn’t eat the whole batch in one night (if that makes sense, believe me it’s a good thing, haha!) The recipe was easy to follow and I love the extra suggestions that are usually included at the end of your recipes because I always find them super helpful. For example, I added a dash of non-dairy milk because our peanut butter was too thick, and it made the batter perfect. Thanks again Minimalist Baker!

    Reply
  57. Bre L-Rsays

    Really simple to make, and I already had everything on hand which made for a quick late-night treat! You’ve done it again MB!! Thanks for another awesome recipe!

    Reply
  58. Aditisays

    Made this so many times and my husband loves it! I am not a baker by any stretch of imagination but this is so easy to follow. Thank you!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Aditi. We are so glad you both enjoy them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  59. Hollysays

    Tried this recipe today and loved it! So easy to make – I love that I don’t have to take out the mixer for this recipe. I substituted All Purpose bleached flour because it was all I had. I also used regular rolled oats (not gluten free). My husband and toddler love the cookies too which is a win for me. This recipe made 12 cookies as it states. They are so good that I ended up making a 2nd batch. The cookies didn’t flatten out as much as shown in the pictures but I’m guessing that’s because of the flour I used – and I don’t mind because they still taste great. I’ll definitely make these again!

    Reply
  60. Louisesays

    I love this recipe, thanks! I made them into lactation cookies by adding brewers yeast and some LSA for added goodness.

    Reply
  61. Haileysays

    I giggled when I read, “and last in the fridge up to a week”….because lucky if they’ll last 2 days!

    I used almond flour and coconut sugar and they taste great! I did have to bake them a bit longer and used a little more almond flour than the recipe called for (but could be due to my PB), but otherwise no issues.

    These are wonderful, will definitely be baking them again. Thank you!

    Reply
  62. Adelasays

    Absolutely love these.

    I made them with all-purpose flour and half light brown / half coconut sugar. I also used whole earth smooth peanut butter and gave it 15 seconds in the microwave as I was towards the end of the tub so the PB was a little stiffer.

    Baked for 10 mins at 160 fan, turning half way through and they cam out perfectly.

    Love your recipes, keep it up!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Aw, thanks so much for the lovely review, Adela! We are so glad you enjoyed these and our other recipes! xo

      Reply
  63. genevieve schneidersays

    I tried subbing the egg for a flax egg and it was very good ! Oui thanks for the recipe :)

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re glad to hear it worked well! Thanks for sharing, Genevieve!

      Reply
  64. Jesssays

    Excellent cookie and so quick. I used 1/2 rice flour 1/2 almond and added hemp hearts.
    Next time I’ll try half the brown sugar.

    Reply
  65. Deesays

    Just finished baking these cookies but didn’t have any chocolate chips so I made them without. I put peanuts on top to press the dough down. The cookies turned out and are delicious! Thanks for another great recipe!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad they turned out well! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  66. Nataliasays

    These cookies are amazing. I think I’ve made them about 5 times now. I sub almond butter for the peanut butter, and always make a double batch because they never last!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoy them, Natalia! Thanks so much for the lovely review!

      Reply
  67. Autumnsays

    YUM!! These sure hit the peanut butter cookie need spot! The “healthy only” cookie person (me) and the “must taste super” cookie person (husband) both loved these. I made exactly as stated, using freshly ground oats for the flour. I did need the extra little bit of flour the recipe said might be needed to make the dough a little less wet (about a tablespoon). I made 16 perfectly delicious cookies. Baked 12 minutes at 350–they were a little crispy on the edges and soft in the middle.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Whoop! We’re so glad you both enjoyed them, Autumn! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  68. Paula Willmssays

    This was such an easy and healthy recipe! I love it! And so does my hubby 😊

    Reply
  69. Nicolesays

    These cookies were great! I doubled the recipe and added a splash of oat milk as my dough wasn’t dry but it was quite crumbly. I also used a GF flour made with a recipe from the Bob’s Red Mill website (NOT their store-bought baking mix). I made my cookies using a 3 tbsp. ice cream scoop and slightly pressed them down with a fork. I increased the baking time to 15 minutes to account for the larger size of the cookies and ensure they were fully cooked throughout. I also didn’t have any baking powder and I subbed 1 tsp of baking soda instead (there was none of the bitterness that using too much baking soda can produce). The cookies turned out crispy on the edges and soft in the middle. It may be a good idea for anyone making these on a hot day to chill the dough a little so their higher fat content doesn’t make them spread too much in the oven.

    Reply
  70. Soniasays

    Heyy this recipe tasted amazing but i had a problem the cookies didnt get bigger in size even the shape was still the same do you have any idea why? I used regular flour tho

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hmm, it could be the all purpose flour as we’ve never tried them. Did you press down on them slightly? We’d also recommend watching the video for additional guidance!

      Reply
  71. Amanda Axlersays

    I’m not a baker and these turned out amazing! This recipe only made about 10 cookies though (although I did leave out the choc chips and it was still delicious). Will be making again!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad they turned out well! Thanks for sharing, Amanda!

      Reply
  72. Cristinasays

    Thanks, Dana! I just made a batch of these for a second night in a row because the first batch went FAST! I used flax eggs, coconut sugar, and almond butter and I wouldn’t change a thing. With my variations they haven’t spread out like other reviewers mentioned. Thanks again!

    Reply
  73. Madisays

    These are so easy and turned out to be so delicious! My new go-to cookie recipe

    Reply
  74. Tori Lambsays

    I used a flax egg and standard plain flour, worked beautifully and they taste delicious! Easy and fast to make.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them! Thanks for sharing, Tori! xo

      Reply
  75. Glennasays

    I made these just now and I’m really surprised this ever got solid reviews. The dough is far too sandy and it’s crumbling apart (even after the cookies have cooled for ten minutes). I’m used to GF flour being fickle, but I used real flour here. I also omitted the chocolate chips because quarantine. I’m not sure what would make this better!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Glenna, two thoughts here: 1) Was your peanut butter creamy/drippy or more dry? 2) Also, we wonder if the all purpose flour could be an issue since it’s more absorbent?

      Reply
      • Glenna Bruckensays

        Very well could be regarding the all purpose flour! I used a creamy/drippy sunflower seed butter per the suggestions (allergic to peanuts and realizing i forgot to mention this substitution in original comment, but the consitency is really on par with creamy peanut butters).

        Reply
    • Nicolesays

      I find that sometimes how well cookies stay together can really change depending on how they’re shaped. Regardless of the type of flour, I’ve found that disher-style ice cream scoops make a big difference in crumbly doughs staying together better. These scoops allow the dough to be packed together, and they’ve been really helpful to me in helping cookies that might otherwise be too crumbly having a good, consistent shape.

      Reply
  76. Erinsays

    Delicious! I doubled the recipe because I knew I would want lots. Easy to make and a perfect gift for a curbside drop off for a friend. I had natural peanut butter but it was unsalted, used coconut sugar and sprinkled Maldon salt on top to feel fancy. Worked out perfectly. TY Dana!

    Reply
  77. diannasays

    boy oh boy! my partner and i made these and loved them. we used coconut sugar in place of the brown sugar and they came out great! the peanut butter is strong at all so if you’re really looking for a peanut butter cookie then this isn’t it but still so WORTH IT. we’ll definitely make these again!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you both enjoyed them, Dianna! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Laetitia! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  78. Chelseasays

    These cookies are delicious!! I’ve made them three times in the last two weeks and keep coming back for more. Love love love them!

    Reply
  79. Carlysays

    Didn’t have any GF flour on hand and needed cookies IMMEDIATELY, so I used All Purpose and turned out wonderful!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad they turned out well! Thanks so much for sharing, Carly!

      Reply
  80. Piasays

    Cant wait to try these cookies. I have all the ingredients but my peanut butter is the crunchy one with flax n chia seeds, will that work? Thank you!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Pia, it should work, but will be more textured. Let us know how it goes!

      Reply
  81. Elishasays

    I doubled the recipe, using almond flour and subbing tahini for peanut butter. I highly recommend sticking to the scoop size suggested here, because these puppies are spreaders. They were so delicious and because there was no oil, butter, or excessive sugar, I didn’t feel bad eating more than one! (I definitely ate more than one.) Will be making again!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Elisha! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  82. Annaliesesays

    These were tasty and not too intensely sweet or peanutty. I halved the sugar and used almond flour. Perfect for what they are – a healthyish peanut butter cookie! Used a 80% cacao chocolate bar for the chocolate and Maldon for sea salt on top. Perfect for after dinner during the week and for breakfast with coffee!

    Reply
  83. rebeccasays

    Made these with 1/4 c of Just Egg, vegan egg substitute, instead of the egg and they were perfect. I also love that it makes a smaller batch of cookies- mine made about 15 small cookies. Plenty for a household of 2!

    Reply
  84. Hillarysays

    These are really yummy, but mine came out too soft. Right after I started making them I realized I didn’t have baking powder. So I used baking soda/lemon juice as a substitute. I also used the Bob’s 1-1 flour. One of those ingredients may have been the reason? I’m not sure. Either way, it was delicious to eat, even if it didn’t stay in form! I love how fast and easy it was.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Hillary, we wonder if the lemon juice added just a bit too much moisture? Next time, we’d say try compensating with a little more flour.

      Reply
  85. SFgirlsays

    Wow, these are AMAZING!!! My husband had a spontaneous wish for a cookie (he never eats cookies) and the options on UberEats were not appealing to me: they would most likely be extremely high in sugar and fat and carb content, as well as take time to deliver and cost a lot.

    I’m so glad I remembered to check Minimalist Baker website for a recipe and this recipe looked simple and delicious. And I had all the ingredients in my pantry already.

    5-10 mins to prep and mix, exactly 10 mins to bake and 5 mins to chill and we had the most delicious cookies I’ve ever tried and/or made!!! I didn’t have to make any changes to the recipe – it was perfect the way it is. The only thing is that I made less cookies but they were bigger. :) So yummy!!!! Totally recommend.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review! We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  86. Janesays

    Great cookie recipe. Whole family loved. Next time I will double recipe. I used almond butter instead of peanut butter due to peanut allergy. Also , used 1/4 cup each of brown sugar and coconut sugar.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad everyone enjoyed them, Jane! Thanks so much for the lovely review!

      Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Mary. We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  87. Brisays

    I absolutely love these cookies!

    Can you use quick cooking rolled oats instead of normal rolled oats? That’s all I have in the house and I’m craving them!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Bri, we’re so glad you enjoy them! We haven’t with quick oats, but it might work!

      Reply
  88. sandrasays

    I did double the recipe and used 2 eggs. I think it was too much egg as the cookies were rubbery. Has anyone else successfully doubled this recipe?

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Sandra- sorry to hear that happened! We haven’t tried doubling it, but we wouldn’t expect it to cause an issue. Did you make any other modifications?

      Reply
  89. Jeanne Douglasssays

    This is my favorite cookie to make now. I use natural almond butter (contains just almonds and salt, creamy or chunky) instead of peanut butter. I also only used 1/4 of the brown sugar (light or dark) only because we are going low carb. I use all amond flour, but I want to try with almond and coconut flour mix. These are delicious healthy cookies.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Jeanne! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  90. Alexasays

    @#%@%@#%@$#[email protected] these are INCREDIBLE! I used a flax egg, coconut sugar, and half pb/half walnut butter (because I ran out of pb). These cookies are so tender and chewy and perfectly sweet. Everything came together so easily and I will definitely be making this regularly.

    First V, GF cookies that turned out great.

    Reply
  91. Janiesays

    Love them! So satisfying and easy to make. I added a bit of cinnamon because I love the taste with peanut butter (: Thanks for the recipe!

    Reply
  92. Sarahsays

    Thanks so much for this! They’re so yummy!
    I used crunchy peanut butter and a flax egg. I needed to use your tip about including a splash of dairy-free milk. It’s little things like these cookies that give us some enjoyment during this weird time. Thank you!

    Reply
  93. Margsays

    I just made this and it is the best gluten free cookie there is, I doubled the recipe and the only changes I made was cut the sugar back to 1/4 cup. I also added approx. 2 tbsp. coconut flour because I thought the dough might be too wet, plus I wanted to use up the coconut flour.
    Excellent recipe!! definitely a keeper.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Marg. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  94. Salena Bakersays

    Delicious! I used coconut flour and 1/4 C stevia/ brown sugar mix with 1/4 coconut sugar to cut down on the sugar. Will definitely make again.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Salena! Thanks so much for sharing!

      Reply
  95. Ssays

    An abomination to both Peanut Butter and Chocolate chip cookies.

    I have enjoyed many minimalist baker recipes but this is neither a peanut butter nor a chocolate chip cookie.

    Here’s a GF, V, DF – PBC

    Peanut Butter Cookie
    ingredients:
    1 Cup Peanut Butter
    1 egg
    3/4 to 1 Cup sugar (brown or white)

    for Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie add:
    1/4 – 1/2 C chocolate chips

    Reply
    • Karensays

      I’ve seen that recipe but couldn’t stomach trying it with all that sugar. This is why I tried this recipe! Perfect for us!

      Reply
  96. Veronikasays

    HI, Thanks for posting this recipe i will definitely try this.
    Keep it up and keep posting.

    Reply
  97. Kaysays

    Great recipe! Made exactly as recommended and cookies came out great. Next tim, I’d reduce the sugar by 1/3 (they were a tad too sweet) and remove them from the baking tray as soon as they come out of the oven as I like a chewy cookie.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks for sharing your experience, Kay! We’re so glad you enjoyed them!

      Reply
  98. Justinatorsays

    I might skip the rolled oats. Should I add more flour? Also, how do you think it will come out if I used Stevia? Sugar substitutes are typically sweeter than sugar, but I still want to add brown sugar. Would 1/4 cup of brown sugar and 1/8 a cup of Stevia be ok?

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi, we haven’t tried with stevia, but we think that might work! If skipping oats, we’d suggest more flour and/or maybe adding some chopped nuts? Hope that helps!

      Reply
      • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

        We haven’t tried that but scan the comments as others have shared their successes!

        Reply
        • Shreyasays

          They turned out amazing ,! Thank you
          We had chocolate peanut butter at home so I reduced the sugar, and used flax egg instead of egg

          Reply
  99. Lexisays

    These do not disappoint! I am vegan so I subbed the egg for 1/4 c aquafaba and used 1/3 c of brown sugar instead (I didn’t want them too sweet) and they came out amazing! Would definitely recommend and will be making again very soon!

    Reply
  100. Jaimesays

    Hi these cookies look amazing! I was wondering if you could use pics crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy peanut butter?

    Reply
  101. Gabriellesays

    These are so good!! I made them with AP flour, a bit less sugar and had to eyeball the teaspoon measurements because I don’t have measuring spoons. The first time I had peanut butter cookies, ages and ages ago, I hated them – too sweet, too peanutty – and never wanted to touch another. I thought I’d give these a try because it seemed a low risk way to try the cookies again and I’d be making them myself. I found the peanut butter flavour just right, loved the chew of the oatmeal, and anything with chocolate has my name on it. Thanks so much! I’ll definitely be making them again and have shared the recipe with my friends.

    Reply
  102. Gabriellesays

    These are so good! I made them w/AP flour and had to eyeball the teaspoon measurements because I don’t have any measuring spoons. I’d only had peanut butter cookies once before this, forever ago, and I hated them. I really wanted dessert though, and had all the ingredients already in my cupboard. I found the peanut butter flavour just right, I love the chew of the oatmeal and anything with chocolate has my name on it. My chips were 70% cocoa. I’ll definitely be making these again and I’ve shared the recipe with my friends! Thanks so much!

    Reply
      • Gabriellesays

        You’re welcome! Sorry for the double comment. It looked like my first one didn’t go through so I tried again.

        Reply
  103. Bituinsays

    This recipe was absolutely divine! I used almond flour and ended up baking for 13 min. Thank you SO much!

    Reply
  104. Lizasays

    Thanks for this yummy cookie recipe :) The only part that did not turn out well for me is the size. It didnt expand as wide as yours in the picture. I think i might have pressed it too far down after putting more choc chips. Do you have an idea what might have happened? I want to make another batch in the future. Thanks, Dana!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Liza, it sounds like maybe we used more dough per cookie? We’re glad you enjoyed them though!

      Reply
  105. Beatrizsays

    Delicious ! I’ve made these twice now. Works just as well with a flax egg. Both times I only used 1/4 cup sugar as I don’t have a big sweet tooth. I also used almond flour as it’s what I have on hand. I’ll have to try this with almond butter next!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Julz, If you try subbing maple syrup you’ll likely need more dry ingredients to compensate a wetter texture. Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
  106. Marsays

    Really good but way too sweet, half the amount of sugar would have been fine. Aside from that, awesome, easy and simple to make. :)

    Reply
  107. Charissesays

    Thanks for sharing the recipe. I love Peanut butter and chocolate and this is a healthier cookie using that combo – I just had to try this recipe. I made 1 batch first to see how they would turn out – used almond flour, Xylitol sugar and baked for 14min. They came out perfectly and are absolutely delicious! Made some more 2 days later so that I could freeze some – didn’t make it to the freezer :) I will definitely make these again.

    Reply
  108. Clairesays

    Sadly, I wasn’t impressed like I always am with MB recipes. My PB was super fresh (brand-new jar!) but the peanut flavor wasn’t pronounced in the final cookie. In my haste I read past the step that said to flatten the dough, so that may have impacted the final result. I used all-purpose flour and added a little bit more to the dough since it seemed too wet. I was too lazy to chop my dark chocolate, and I used big chips, so scooping the dough was also a little awkward.

    Overall, this may have been down to baker error, but I just didn’t care for the overall taste/texture of these cookies :'(

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Claire, sorry to hear they didn’t turn out as expected! We haven’t tried these with all-purpose and wonder if that may have been the issue?

      Reply
      • Clairesays

        Sadly, yes, I think that may have been the cause. It’s okay, my bf still devoured them, haha

        Reply
  109. Brynne Parisesays

    Absolutely delicious! I have Celiac so always looking for gluten free cookie recipes. These are light and have a wonderful texture. Used almond flour. Will definitely make again and have already shared it! Thank you!

    Reply
  110. Rachelsays

    YUMMM.
    These cookies are amazing. They came together so quick and made a perfect dozen! These cookies took me less than 30 minutes to prep and bake (and eat dipped with cashew milk). I didn’t have chocolate chips on hand so I used a chunk or dark salted chocolate I had in the cupboard chopped roughly. Because my chocolate was salted I didn’t add the sprinkle at the end. 10/10 would bake again!

    Reply
  111. Anniesays

    wow these are delicious!! The perfect amount of sweetness and chewiness. I used maple sugar and it turned out great. thank you Dana!

    Reply
    • Katiesays

      Delicious! I love peanut butter cookies, but I’ve never found a healthier alternative recipe (that was actually good) until now! By far the easiest and fastest baking session to date- so thank you!
      I used almond flour, half coconut sugar, half brown, and unsalted peanut butter. Baked for 12 minutes and they turned out soo good once cooled, perfectly chewy in the middle.

      Reply
  112. Barbarasays

    Perfect recipe, thank you Dana ! I only leave them 15 minutes in the oven instead of 12, delicious!

    Reply
  113. Francessays

    DELICIOUS! Was craving PB cookies today and these came together so quick! I made some without chocolate chips and some with – both are so good. Will try with flax seed next time and see how they do – saw it worked in someone else’s version. Thank you for this perfect recipe!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Frances! Thanks for sharing!

      Reply
  114. Emilysays

    I can’t stop making these. I enjoy big cookies so I usually only get about 9 cookies but its perfect for a single pan bake session.
    I also enjoy this recipe with whole wheat flour and milk chocolate chips – thank you for the recipe!

    Reply
  115. Tessasays

    I really liked these! Easy and delicious.
    I used a combination of coconut flour and regular plain flour instead of gluten-free flour and they turned out really well. I had to add more coconut flour because my peanut butter was a runnier texture. I forgot to flatten them before putting them in the oven and baked them for about 13 minutes. They have a really nice, chewy texture, however the bottoms were much more cooked than the tops. Still delicious and I recommend that you try them!

    Reply
  116. Yussrasays

    They were super tasty and quick. They will definitely be a staple in our household. Thanks!

    Reply
  117. Chiquisays

    Really AMAZING cookies. I only change the baking time to 15 mins.
    Highly recommended!

    Reply
  118. Nicole Ksays

    I normally don’t post reviews for recipes but this one was that amazing. I had no butter and have a gluten allergy so I really thought I wouldn’t be able to make any cookies but this totally worked. Used ground up almonds for the flour and the recipe still turned out chewy and not dense.

    Reply
  119. Kimsays

    Just made these and they are delicious! I didn’t necessarily need them to be gluten-free, so I used whole wheat pastry flour. I think the peanut butter I used was pretty salty, so they probably didn’t need the 1/4 teaspoon of salt. It definitely makes them very flavorful though! A very quick and easy recipe, and I appreciate how it made a reasonable number (12) of a cookies!

    Reply
  120. JDsays

    I made these, I added a little unsweetened applesauce to the mixture instead of milk. The cookies turned out absolutely delicious! The cookies were moist, not overly sweet, just right.

    Reply
  121. helenasays

    These.Are.Amazing. simple, quick and delicious- everything you’ll ever need in a cookie!

    Reply
  122. Laurensays

    I’ve made these four times now! So good! I have consistently needed to add more flour but it may be due to the consistency of the peanut butter I’m using.

    Reply
  123. Aryannasays

    Literally amazing! Was craving something sweet and already had all of the ingredients in the house! I didn’t have natural peanut butter so I used regular. I had to add a bit of almond flour as suggested since they were a bit too wet at first. Turned out perfect! Great taste, simple ingredients, easy to clean up – 5/5 stars from me!!!

    Reply
  124. Brittany Sharpesays

    Hi Dana!! These look so good! Can I sub maple syrup from brown sugar? Hoping to make these today! Love you and your amazing recipes. :)

    Britt & Berlin

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Britt & Berlin! Thanks so much! If you try subbing maple syrup you’ll likely need more dry ingredients to compensate a wetter texture. Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
  125. Emanuela Tognisays

    We didn’t like the flavour very much. My husband said they taste like cardboard.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Sorry to hear that was your experience, Emanuela! These should be quite flavorful. Did you make any modifications?

      Reply
  126. Sallysays

    Absolutely delicious…..I think? They never actually made it to the oven, the dough was too good to resist!?So, have to make some more…..for research purposes!

    Reply
  127. Hanasays

    The perfect cookie! I used almond flour and these turned out amazing. Great texture and perfectly sweet! This is now my go-to when I’m craving something quick, easy and tasty!!

    Reply
  128. Kasiesays

    Sooo yummy!! We did a flax egg in place of a regular egg. Will definitely make again. They were perfect to make with my toddler. ??

    Reply
  129. Rebeccasays

    Great Recipe. My 10 year old son wanted to bake this was the perfect recipe for him.

    Reply
  130. Ginasays

    Just made these and OMG!! Sooooo good, I love anything peanut butter but these blew my mind! I had three? wanted to go for my fourth to be honest but held back ha! These will definitely be on repeat. Thank you so much!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Ha! We are so glad you are enjoying them, Gina! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi there – we have the option to toggle back and forth between standard and metric in the recipe box just above the ingredients list!

      Reply
  131. Helenasays

    Really great recipe :) so easy and gooood!
    Comforting for cold days.

    Thanks for sharing!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Helena. We are so glad you enjoy it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  132. Jaimesays

    So tasty and chewy, a perfect snack during this quarantine. Super fast and easy to make, I look forward to making them again

    Reply
  133. Samuelsays

    This is the best cookie recipe ever!!!
    It’s so good and it’s vegan and gluten-free !!
    Thanks so much!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Samuel. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  134. A. Valentinosays

    Due to being restricted to what I already have in my pantry during the pandemic I made this with a few substitutions:

    -Peanuts processed to a powder in food processor with oil added to bring closer to nut butter consistency
    -all-purpose baking flour
    -coconut sugar
    -a dash of almond milk added to the egg because it was a small egg

    Turned out great – they are super nutty, salty-sweet, and comforting. Thanks for the recipe!

    Reply
  135. Wendy Raymersays

    These are so good and chewy and peanut buttery! Just what I wanted! I baked them for 16 minutes because they didn’t seem quite done at 12. Thanks for another fabulous recipe!

    Reply
  136. Ruth Bellsays

    I just made these cookies. I used Nut Butter from Costco, almond flour and coconut sugar and cacao nibs in the cookies with chocolate chips on the top and the rest of the ingredients you called for. They are delicious. They took 15 minutes in our oven. They are chewy. Thanks for the great recipe. I will try them with peanut butter when I get some.

    Reply
  137. Kathleensays

    Absolutely delicious. I did not use gluten free flour. So easy to throw together. Minimal clean up. I will make theses again and again.

    Reply
  138. Marylizsays

    OMG! I just made these! I used coconut sugar and since I ran out of vanilla extract, I used maple syrup (which is what Google told me to do! Lol) Also, by mistake I had bought chunky peanut butter and never got around exchanging it. Guess what? I loved the extra bits of peanuts! Also forgot to chop the chocolate chips so it’s extra chocolaty chunky! They came out perfect! Wish I could attach a picture! Delicious!!! I actually don’t think I’ll share as I want them all to myself! Lol! ;-) I’ll share the next batch! ;-))) I love your recipes! Have tried many! Keep up the great job Ms Minimalista Baker! <3

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoy them!! Thanks so much for your kind words and lovely review! xo

      Reply
  139. Janell Dixonsays

    I watched Leanne Morgan on her FB page talking about having just made these cookies so I thought I’d try them. They were great. I used regular peanut butter and had to cook them a bit longer but they were delicious!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks for sharing, Janell! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

      Reply
  140. Emilysays

    I love this recipe! Super simple and delicious. I make these with almond flour and they turn out fabulous!

    Reply
  141. Melaniesays

    Amazing! Truly one of my all time favorites – the cookies turn out beautiful and are so soft. Excellent recipe. Thank you!!!

    Reply
  142. Cristina S.says

    Great recipe! I made them with my daughter in this trouble times, as an stay at home activity. I would also suggest to use a bit less sugar, I used 1/4 cup brown sugar and 1/4 cup coconut sugar and almond flour. My daughter and husband want to eat them all.
    Thanks so much from Costa Rica. ?

    Reply
    • Nancy Collettsays

      Being stuck in Toronto during a state of emergency what else to do but bake. You’ve inspired me. And to think those were made in Costa Rica a few short days ago. So almond flour works fine?
      So inspired. Well, must be made here then!

      Reply
      • Amysays

        We made it with almond flour and added 1/4 cup shredded coconut, some crushed pecans, a tbsp of chia seeds, and added a splash of almond milk to compensate and they turned out delicious too! (We have so much Costco chia my goodness)

        Reply
        • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

          Thanks so much for the lovely review, Amy. We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

          Reply
  143. Parveensays

    These cookies are delicious! I also used less sugar than the recipe called for. Thanks for sharing this recipe Minimalist Baker! I love your blog, it’s the absolute best! keep up the good work!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Aw, thanks so much for your kind words and lovely review, Parveen! Thanks for sharing!

      Reply
  144. Danielle Csays

    Wonderful Recipe! I used half the amount of sugar listed in the ingredients since I’m not too much of a sweet lover and they were delicious!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Danielle. We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  145. Laurensays

    I’ve been looking for a healthier peanut butter cookie recipe like this, so glad to have found it! I am vegan, so I used mashed banana as another reviewer said that worked well. I also reduced the sugar by 1/4 based on other reviews, I think I would reduce it even more when making them for myself, as I have less of a sweet tooth. I love how easy these were to mix up and bake, it was so quick and easy! Thanks for the recipe!

    Reply
  146. admattaisays

    I made these cookies and they are delicious! I used what I had at home so I used 1/4 cup (1 packet of instant oatmeal) and 1/4 cup all purpose flour. I also used Enjoy Life dark chocolate chips and organic natural creamy pb.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review and for sharing your modifications, Admattai. We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  147. Anne Sinclairsays

    I loved making these and shared them with the family and stashed some in the Pandemic freezer pantry. But I want more so I am making another batch tonight. Stay well everyone. Please don’t panic shop.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Anne. We are so glad you enjoy this recipe! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  148. EGsays

    This recipe is fantastic! I made these on a whim with ingredients I already had on hand, so ended up swapping the peanut butter for almond butter and used regular flour instead of GF, and they turned out so so good! Chewy, chocolaty, sweet and salty, just delicious! This recipe is definitely a keeper, I’m already planning my next batch because this one won’t last long. Thanks Dana and team!

    Reply
  149. Kimsays

    So…..although oats are gluten free, they are hard for me to digest. Is there an option without the oats? Maybe a higher amount of GF flour blend? Thanks!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Kim, we haven’t tried substituting out the oats so we can’t say for sure. But we think maybe additional GF flour or almond flour might work! Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
  150. Sophiesays

    My new favorite cookie recipe! It’s so easy to make on a whim and I actually love making these with chunky peanut butter! Soooo yummy.

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      We’re so glad you enjoy them, Sophie! Thanks so much for the lovely review!

      Reply
  151. Naomisays

    Would the recipe work if I omitted the chocolate chips (I know, horror of horrors! I just enjoy plain old peanut butter cookies.)?

    Reply
  152. Leonasays

    This cookies are simple and delicious! I made them the first time and they were delicious but a little too sweet for me. So, I made them a second time, but this time I used half the sugar and only 2 tbs of chocolate chips, and added I tbs of hemp seeds. They turned out perfect! Thanks for your recipe!!

    Reply
  153. Mireillesays

    Made these today. They were SO good!!! Thanks for all the amazing recipes! There’s not a week that goes by that I don’t make a recipe of yours! :)

    Reply
  154. Morgansays

    These cookies are made with simple ingredients you most likely have on hand, quick to make, and deliciously satisfying! I substituted 1 tsp maple syrup for the 1/2 tsp of vanilla and they tasted great. I can definitely see these becoming part of my regular sweet treat rotation :-) Love how the recipe allows for so much creativity as well!

    Reply
  155. Stephaniesays

    These are seriously the simplest to make but most satisfying peanut butter cookies!! So delicious!!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Stephanie. We are so glad you enjoyed them! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

      Reply
  156. Katrinasays

    These were delicious and so easy to make! I substituted 1/4 cup mashed banana for the egg and ground oats for the gf flour, and they came out great.

    Reply
  157. Annasays

    These are dangerously easy to make and so so good! The perfect combo of sweet and salty, with a nice soft chewy texture from the oats. Definitely one of the best (if not the best) gluten free cookies that I have ever had!

    Reply
    • Support @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Whoop! We’re so glad you enjoyed them, Anna! Thanks so much for the lovely review!

      Reply
  158. Kathysays

    I’ve made these twice this week (and might make them again tonight!). They come together so quick and clean up is easy. They are so delicious. Love love love.

    Reply
  159. Mariasays

    Just made these cookies with my toddler and we had fun baking them! There are so easy and quick. We loved them! We used wheat flour and they turned out great! Will try with GF next time!

    Reply
  160. Samina Ahmedsays

    I made this last night – 5/5. All devoured. Used almond flour.

    Going to make them again tonight but will reduce sugar to 1/3 cup as we found 1/2 cup sugar delicious but a bit too sweet.

    Thank you!

    Reply
  161. Chrissays

    Made this for my peanut butter-loving Valentine… we both loved it!! I agree with the other reviews, easy recipe and the cookies taste great! Thanks for sharing!!

    Reply
  162. Sherriesays

    Just made these and YUM! My daughter is vegan so I used a little under a quarter cup of Just Egg instead of the egg in the recipe. And since I didn’t have any gluten free flour on hand, I just blended a quarter cup of the GF oats for the flour. They turned out delicious — I’m keeping this recipe for sure!

    Reply
  163. Nicolesays

    These are delicious, and so quick and easy to make. I didn’t have oats, so used almond flour. I also substituted coconut sugar. Yum! Thank you for a super recipe!

    Reply
  164. Cassie Doolittlesays

    I’ve made them twice this week! Very peanut buttery and yummy. Kids like ‘em. Easy to make. Thank you!

    Reply
  165. Lizsays

    Super easy to make and tasted delicious! Making a second batch the day after because they were such a hit.

    Reply
  166. Amyleesays

    I made these with coconut sugar instead of the brown sugar and almond butter instead of peanut butter (just using what I had on hand!). I also used almond flour. They turned out great! And easy clean up since it was all in one bowl :) I’ll definitely make these again!

    Reply
  167. Lauriano Tanosays

    I made a vegan version by replacing the egg with 1/4 cup aquafaba and they turned out perfect! I also used 1/4 cup organic cane sugar instead of 1/2 cup brown sugar and they turned sweet enough. I’m glad I didn’t add any more sugar!

    I’m wondering though if I could replace the sugar with real maple syrup so it’s more nutritious? Thanks.

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Wonderful! Thanks for sharing. If you try subbing maple syrup you’ll likely need more dry ingredients to compensate a wetter texture. Let us know if you try it!

      Reply
  168. Nicole Madsensays

    I made these yesterday! I substituted flax (1 tablespoon of flax meal plus 3 tablespoons of water) for the hen period. I also added 1 tablespoon of oat milk into the batter since mine seemed to be a bit dry. The cookies turned out delicious! Super peanut buttery and sweet! I will definitely make these again soon.

    Reply
  169. Alyssasays

    These turned out great! Followed the recipe exactly (had to warm up my PB as it stays in the fridge and thus was not creamy) and had no issues. It came together really quickly. I can tell this will be a new go-to cookie recipe for me in the future. It made 12 cookies exactly, so it’ll be easy to double if needed.

    Another winning recipe, Dana and team!

    Reply
  170. Monasays

    So I made these last night and now I’m making them again. This time, though, I’m doubling the recipe because 4 of my kids inhaled the 12 cookies in like 3.2 nanoseconds… faster than kid #5 could get to them! These were super-easy and super-quick to make. The only change I made was using regular non-drippy peanut butter (Jif) because that’s all I had. They were perfect! Thank you, Dana, for yet another fantastic recipe!

    Reply
  171. Marinasays

    yummy and not too sweet.

    I doubled the batch and subbed the brown sugar for organic coconut sugar. I reduced it from 1 cup (1/2 cup if single batch) to 3/4 of a cup and it was great.

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yay! Thanks for sharing, Marina! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

      Reply
  172. Elizabethsays

    What a great recipe, so easy and delicious! I usually have MB’s gluten free flour mix on hand but was out so used Bob’s Red Mill gluten free flour instead. I like crispier cookies so these stayed in the oven for an extra four minutes (I also live at a high altitude and that affects cooking time sometimes too). Just finished a second batch and saw in the recipe the addition of salt on top of the cookies when cooling…ran into the kitchen to sprinkle some Maldon sea salt flakes on the cooling cookies and am looking forward to tasting that special addition!

    Reply
  173. Silviasays

    Amazing recipe! Didn’t last long after out of the oven ? I used almond butter instead and worked well.
    The only thing I noted is that I had to use double the time in the oven, but again the cookies were fantastic!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks, Sea! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

      Reply
  174. Nicolesays

    Delicious – my three boys all voted 5 stars and are currently demolishing them. These will be made regularly now, most likely tomorrow, as they’ll all be eaten. I love this recipe because it’s so easy to whip up and I didn’t change a thing. They came out perfectly – Thanks Dana!

    Reply
  175. sunnybabysays

    Appreciated the simplicity of the recipe.

    Adaptations (based on what was available to me): 1) No peanut butter so used almond butter instead; 2) No chocolate chips, so used equal amount cocoa powder; 3) No vanilla so omitted. Did not add more sea salt on top of each cookie. Used the Minimalist Baker GF flour and otherwise followed the recipe as is. Made in a single batch, and liked it so much, I made another – this time a double batch.

    Results: Delivered the expected of servings. Tastes good despite the adaptations. Salty and sweet. Did not expand to double as recipe indicated, but didn’t make a difference to me.

    Definitely keeping this one back pocket – thanks!

    Reply
  176. Bethsays

    Excellent recipe. I doubled the recipe, but it only made about 16-18 small cookies. I also halved the sugar and used 50:50 coconut and brown sugar, which may have contributed the batch size. Would make again!

    Reply
  177. Allisonsays

    Loved these. Mine came out a little flat. Probably because I used local organic oats which are very tender/soft and I used homemade peanut butter. I used white whole wheat flour. The taste was amazing, so easy to make. I used Lily chocolate chips because I had them on hand, don’t really like them much, but they were good in these cookies! These were such a hit, I made a double batch for the freezer the next day.

    Reply
  178. Annesays

    Yummy. This is a keeper.
    Different continent, different peanut butter, my cookies did not expend. I could probably press them a little more before baking then. But event with pressing them only a little, i like them a lot. Taste and look.
    The peanut butter i used is actually 100% peanuts (no salt). The quantity of « fleur de sel » i used for the recipe still makes it perfectly balanced to my taste. Would not add more.
    If I am not mistaken, you mention (in the ingredients) salt for in the dough and somehow on top.. but I did not see it mentioned in the recipe so was wondering if you suggest to add some salt on top of the cookies as well before baking.
    Thanks a lot for the metric conversion too ! Made my life soooo much easier :-)

    Reply
      • Annesays

        My third (or fourth already, who is counting anyways… :-) ) batch is in the oven right now ! Told you it was a keeper. Love them. Very quick to make and loved by anyone who has tried them so far.
        By the way (note to self) : love them with only 60 g of light muscovado sugar.
        One more minute and they are readyyyyyy. Can’t wait :-D

        Reply
  179. Amysays

    These are very quick & easy to make. I doubled the recipe and it made around 32 cookies (perhaps I made them smaller than original recipe?). I didn’t add extra choc chip on top. They are SO GOOD! Will definitely make again.

    Reply
  180. whitsays

    Just made these. I have to say the raw dough tasted darn good. The cookies were quite good, but rather crumbly. I used half gf flour and half almond flour. I think next time I would put half the amount of sugar and wouldnt add in extra salt because I think the salt from the PB was enough. But definitely a good foundation and the flavour is there!

    Reply
  181. Isabellesays

    These were so delicious! Honestly, just perfect. I love how strong the peanut butter flavour was.

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Yes! Let them thaw slightly (~15-30 minutes) then bake at 350F until slightly browned on the edges.

      Reply
  182. Wilheminasays

    This recipe is so simple and the cookies are delicious.
    I experimented by adding some dried cherries, unsweetened shredded coconut coconut sugar and more peanut butter. The cookies were even better!
    Thank you so very much for this recipe. I’m always looking for
    a healthy treat that is dairy and gluten free.

    Reply
  183. Juliesays

    Loved how quick these are to make. I reduced sugar to 1 T, subbed half the pb with pb powder, and used 2T chocolate chips. Had to add a tad more oat flour because of the pb sub, but they turned out great.

    Reply
  184. Chelseasays

    So quick, so easy, so tasty! I used standard all-purpose flour, and added some mini M&Ms which gave it a delightful crunch. I made these with my two-year-old daughter and she loved helping make and eat them. :)

    Reply
  185. Vickysays

    Great cookies! I substituted the egg with awuafaba, (2/4 cups) and they turned out great! They didn’t double their size tho, They got a bit bigger but not doubbled. Otherwise they taste great and my toddler loves them and so does my husband, thank you for your awesome recipes ?

    Reply
  186. Krissays

    These are great! I used all-purpose flour and replaced the egg with 3 tbsp aquafaba (unwhipped). The texture is soft but not crumbly and they taste delicious!

    Reply
  187. Annasays

    Had all these ingredients on hand and whipped up these cookies last night- sooo dangerously easy and good! I had unsalted PB so just increased the salt to ~1/2 tsp and they were salty sweet and perfect

    Reply
  188. Audreysays

    I have made these twice now. First time with double the recipe size of rolled oats & 1/4 Cup almond flour. I only had natural pb without salt but found the 1/4 tsp in your regular recipe enough. Used coconut sugar instead of brown. Second time I made oat flour out of 1/2 the rolled oats and just used that with the rolled oats – same other substitutions as above. Each made about 20 small cookies and took about 14 mins to bake switching 2 cookie pans 1/2 way between top and bottom. Great reviews from family and friends each time. Thank you so much for your creative and easy recipes.

    Reply
  189. Ambersays

    Just made these and they are DEEEEEEEeeeee-licious!
    I used teddy bear natural peanut butter super chunky and it worked great. it is not an overly pourable natural peanut butter and they still came out perfect. used a tad more vanilla extract and used regular white flour. yum! I only wish I had made a double or triple batch. these will be gone in no time. thank you!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Wonderful! Thanks for sharing, Paloma! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

      Reply
  190. Judy Chansays

    thanks a lot for sharing! If I want to make it vegan, can I replace the egg with, for example, chia seeds? If so what is the proportion of chia seeds and water to be used? Please kindly advise! Many thanks! Have a good one!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi, Judy! I haven’t tried these with an egg replacer. But if you try a chia egg, let us know how it goes! I’d probably recommend aquafaba instead. Check out this Guide to Egg Substitutes for details on these substitutes and more.

      Reply
  191. Emmanuellesays

    These are soooo good WOW! With the salt ?

    We replaced with flax egg, almond butter and all-purpose flour and it was perfectly delicious. Didn’t rise as much, but were tasty chunky cookies! Will definitely do them again.

    Reply
  192. Laurie Bozeksays

    Do you have any suggestions for what I could substitute for the egg? Maybe pureed prune or applesauce?

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Others have had success with a flax egg. I’d personally go with aquafaba. If you try any others, let us know how it goes!

      Reply
  193. Jensays

    I made these today, as written, and they are great! Soft, chewy, perfectly peanut buttery and studded with chocolate chips! Yum!!

    Reply
  194. Elliesays

    Hi Dana from BC, Canada
    Like the recipe. Made tonight for a play rehearsal.
    I used half and half garbanzo and coconut flours. Worked fine.
    Used coconut sugar. Will use date sugar in the future as well.
    Doubled recipe and only made 22 small cookies.
    Quality, not quantity, right?
    Thanks for all you do.
    I have your cookbook!
    The coconut red curry veg soup recipe is fantastic!!! Sooo flavourful.
    Will make repeatedly!!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks for sharing, Ellie! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

      Reply
  195. Amber Jsays

    This is probably the best PB cookie over ever tasted. I used almond flour, Aldi brand PB and mini chocolate chips. The taste and texture are fabulous. PB cookies are usually slightly greasy, they were not. Next time I’ll have to double the recipe since I have 3 boys and a hubby I have to share they with. I appreciate the notes making it customizable for you dietary needs. THANK YOU for your trial and error perfecting this cookie!

    Reply
  196. AnneKasays

    Could you replace the egg with a flax or chia egg to veganize this? Or would you suggest any other egg alternatives?

    Reply
  197. Katsays

    If you sub aquafaba, do you have to whip it? Or can you use plain aquafaba straight out of the can?

    I don’t have an electric mixer :(.

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      You can certainly try it without whipping. I’d suggest whipping primarily to help them be more airy and rise. But let us know how it goes! I recommend (and personally use) a handheld electric mixer (which are usually quite affordable).

      Reply
  198. Heidisays

    Hi there, these look delicious. What would happen if I skipped the sugar completely? Think it would still work?
    Thank you!
    Heidi

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Hi Heidi! I think you’d want some sweetness from somewhere. But texturally they should be fine. Just add more dry ingredients of choice to compensate for a drier texture.

      Reply
  199. Paige Cassandra Flammsays

    These look amazing! Totally going to make them with the kids after school today!

    Reply
  200. Chersays

    Super good! I only had almond butter so used that instead and also used coconut sugar. I will be baking them again for sure!!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks for sharing, Cher! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

      Reply
  201. Ritasays

    I had all the ingredients on hand so made it right away! I’ve never made/eaten GF cookie before so I didn’t know what to expect but it wasn’t quite traditional cookie-like. It almost tasted like just sugar and PB, and I wish there was little more flour/dough-y taste? Also it’s very sweet, so I might lessen the sugar next time and add more oats/GF flour maybe. Anyway, I recently went GF, so thank you for another easy recipe!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      Thanks for sharing, Rita! You could always cut back on sugar and replace it with GF flour, as that will provide a more flour-y, less sweet texture/flavor!

      Reply
  202. Annsays

    I ould love to make thses but I have an intolerance for oats for reasons other than they contain gluten. Will it change the results much if I leave them out? Thanks!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      I don’t think so. Just add more dry ingredients as needed to compensate for a wetter batter.

      Reply
  203. Lisasays

    Can I use plain flour? I also have smooth almond butter – would that work. Trying to use my store cupboard, thanks

    Reply
  204. Sarasays

    I love peanut peanut butter/chocolate combos and have all of these ingredients! I might need to make some either tonight or this weekend.

    Reply
  205. Robin Ludtsays

    Hello: Thank you for all of the great recipes!
    Re: these cookies, would almond (or another nut) butter work in place of peanut butter?

    Reply
  206. Laureesays

    Just made these with regular all purpose flour. They tasted amazing.
    Prep time was actually more of a 5 minute thing.

    Do you think these could be make with almond butter?

    Reply
  207. Raesays

    Have you tried this with an egg replacer like aquafaba or a flax egg to make it vegan? Do you have a recommendation for the best egg replacer for this recipe? Thanks!

    Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      I’d suggest aquafaba, but others have also had success with flax egg. Let us know what you try!

      Reply
    • Dana @ Minimalist Bakersays

      I’d recommend trying aquafaba. But a banana or applesauce may work! Let us know if you give it a try as we haven’t tested any other substitutions.

      Reply